Personal Touch Catering Experience

Caterer

5.0

73 reviews on Google

Personal Touch Catering Experience is a New York City caterer serving weddings, corporate events, and social gatherings, founded by John Policastro and rooted in a hospitality background dating to 1988. The company offers custom menus drawing from global cuisines including modern American, Mediterranean, Italian, Latin, and Asian, with service formats ranging from plated dinners and buffets to interactive food stations, plus full-service planning and vendor coordination. John Policastro opened Mamma Mia restaurant in Hackensack, NJ in 1988, which evolved into Personal Touch Catering and then into Personal Touch Experience in 2014; the leadership team also includes COO Nick, who joined in 2016, and Ashley, who has led the experience team since 2011. Based in New York City, with service extending to New Jersey and Connecticut, operating across venues from Manhattan rooftops and Brooklyn lofts to tented outdoor settings. Reviewers highlight the team's professionalism, flexibility during planning, attentive named contacts (including Nick, Victoria, Ashley, Tony, and Kait), and food quality praised even by self-described critical guests.

Summarised from this business's public listing and website — not written by them. How this works

New York, NY

This vendor hasn’t completed verification

Verified vendors have uploaded credentials such as a business license or proof of insurance, and our team reviewed each document by hand. Verification is a trust signal, not a requirement: you can still reach out, and payments run through Stripe either way.

Personal Touch Catering Experience hasn't claimed their United Vows profile yet, but you can still reach them.

We don't have an email address on file for Personal Touch Catering Experience, so we can't forward an inquiry to them. The way to reach them today is to call (212) 851-8436. You can still send one here — we'll keep it on your inquiries list, and it will be waiting for them the moment they claim this profile.

Two things worth knowing before you transact:

If your booking happens on United Vows: A $100 United Vows welcome or favor credit, if you hold one — this credit comes off one booking here, in full, funded from our commission on it, once that booking is a booking of $2,900 or more, paid to them in a single payment of at least $1,500 — you get messaging, quotes and contracts in one place, your payment runs securely through Stripe against a signed contract, and if the vendor no-shows, cancels close to your date or delivers nothing you can file a claim from the booking, which they have seven days to answer.
If the booking happens off-platform: none of the above. Your credits don't redeem. We can't help if anything goes sideways.

The simplest move: when you reach out, ask Personal Touch Catering Experience to claim their profile. It takes them 60 seconds. It keeps your booking on the platform where everything we built for you actually works.

Sign up to leave a request