Is this your business?

Claim Buttermilk Bakeshop to manage your profile, respond to inquiries, and connect with couples planning their wedding.

4.7 on Google(687 reviews)

Free to claim. We'll verify your ownership via email.

Buttermilk Bakeshop

Listed from public reviewsCRI 100

BAKERY

4.7

687 reviews on Google

"Quaint bakery offering cookies, cupcakes & other desserts along with custom cakes & cooking classes."

Buttermilk Bakeshop is a Brooklyn bakery led by baker Katy, offering custom cakes, cookies, cupcakes, and other desserts baked fresh by hand. Known for hand-crafted cakes and cookies made from scratch using pure ingredients and expert culinary techniques, with vegan and gluten-free options available. Buttermilk Bakeshop operates two locations in Brooklyn: Park Slope at 264 5th Avenue and Gowanus at 530 3rd Avenue, with nationwide shipping available. Couples praise the bakery for custom cake design, delicious flavor, attentive customer service, and stress-free ordering, with one reviewer noting their wedding slice cake was simple, elegant, and exactly what they wanted.

Brooklyn, NY

This vendor hasn't completed verification

Verified vendors have their business license, insurance, and identity checked. They can receive inquiries and accept bookings through our secure escrow system.

Protected by United Vows

Buttermilk Bakeshop hasn't claimed their United Vows profile yet, but you can still reach them.

When you send an inquiry, we'll notify them by email and SMS the same minute. They can call you back directly at (347) 987-3941 or reply by email.

Two things worth knowing before you transact:

If your booking happens on United Vows: your Welcome Credit and any other UV credits redeem against the invoice, you have full access to messaging, contracts, scheduling, and dispute resolution, and your payment is held in Escrow Protection if your vendor has opted in (look for the badge on their profile after they claim).
If the booking happens off-platform: none of the above. Your credits don't redeem. We can't help if anything goes sideways.

The simplest move: when you reach out, ask Buttermilk Bakeshop to claim their profile and turn on Escrow Protection. It takes them 60 seconds. It keeps your booking on the platform where everything we built for you actually works.

Send your inquiry →

Portfolio

No portfolio items yet

Reviews

687 total

No reviews yet. Be the first to leave a review!

Contact Information

(347) 987-3941

Connect with us

Photo credits: Buttermilk Bakeshop, Lilia Deterville, Kay Riv · via Google