"Well-known outfit with a homestyle, Southern vibe for specialty cakes, cheesecakes, cupcakes & pies."
Make My Cake is a Harlem bakery located at 409 W 125th St, New York, offering cakes, cheesecakes, cupcakes, cookies, and pies rooted in Southern baking traditions. The bakery's menu draws from family recipes combining the Southern baking traditions of Mississippi and Alabama with Harlem soul, with signature items including a red velvet cake (a New York Times pick), German Chocolate Cake (a Food Network favorite), and Sweet Potato Cheesecake (a local favorite). The business began as a home-based operation over 22 years ago, founded on recipes developed by matriarch Josephine Smith, known as Ma Smith, and has since expanded to multiple full-service retail and wholesale bakeries. Located at 409 W 125th St in Harlem, New York. Reviewers frequently single out the red velvet cake as moist and delicious, and note that custom cake orders, including wedding and birthday cakes, are handled with a straightforward consultation and deposit process, with orders ready for pickup as promised.
Summarised from this business's public listing and website — not written by them. How this works
Verified vendors have uploaded credentials such as a business license or proof of insurance, and our team reviewed each document by hand. Verification is a trust signal, not a requirement: you can still reach out, and payments run through Stripe either way.
Claim it free. Your profile for Grandma's cake is already started, and we'll draft the rest from your website.
Free to claim. We confirm it's yours through your website, then help you finish the profile.
Ratings from public Google reviews — verified United Vows reviews take over as couples book here.
Photo credits: Domingo Rodríguez, Grandma's cake, Garnett Banfield, Angel Antonio, Jeff T. Critic · via Google